Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Gaetano's Sub Shop. We'd love to have your feedback!

Select a location

You are submitting your information to Gaetano's Sub Shop and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. Popmenu's and apply.

Our Latest Reviews

Kasey about 1 month ago


Kasey here! Embarking on this review is like trying to capture the essence of a sublime Italian sub that's been haunting my daydreams. Picture the finest capicola in the state, cozying up with hard salami, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, provolone, impeccably cut white onions, mayo, and a dash of sub dressing -- all chilling on a cold sub. It's a masterpiece. Quick shoutout to Gaetano's "Inferno Sauce" -- a revelation for a saucy aficionado like me. Seriously, when you swing by for one of their sandwiches, don't sleep on asking for a side of this chipotle heaven. Your taste buds will thank you. Now, let's dive into the experience. Every time I waltz into this joint, it's like a warm welcome party. Multiple team members dish out the friendliness, making the whole experience of grabbing my food downright delightful. The owner is a local legend -- well-known, respected, and a massive supporter of other small businesses in the area. Meeting someone this awesome? Pure thrill. If you're into heavenly subs, killer sauces, and an all-around good vibe, this spot's your haven. Here's to mouthwatering bites and meeting the cool cats behind the counter! ??

Gesse 3 months ago


We are addicted!!!! Steak Sandwich with pepper relish is FIRE! Hoping to grab one tomorrow.

Derek 3 months ago


Gaetano's never misses! SLC is lucky to have such a high quality and consistent sandwich shop. The Italian is always fresh and filling. Has everything I want in a lunchtime sandwich.

Nicholas 4 months ago

Turkey & Provolone

The closest take on an east coast sub that I have found in SLC. Delicious and leagues above the next best out here! I will continue to get sandwiches from Gaetanos for as long as I live Here...wish you had a bar!

Abel 4 months ago

Cream Cheese Jalapeño Poppers (3)

The most amazing poppers I have ever had. Crunchy but yet soft and delicious

Dustin 2 months ago


This place is like a sub shop you see in bigger cities and usually more eastern. But here we are with our very own place right here in SLC. Hell yeah.

Derek 3 months ago


This meatball sandwich plays it pretty straight forward. You know what you are getting every time and it rocks! Unlike most meatball subs, this one holds up really well in a to go situation. I generally like to eat a meatball sub on the spot, but this one makes a great travel companion.

Nicholas 3 months ago


Incredible sandwich, you can blindly pick anything off of their menu and I'm sure it will be fantastic. Best sandwich shop in SLC!

Abel 4 months ago

Chicken Parmigiana

The chicken was above anything else. The sauce and cheese ratio were just right! Delicious

Abel 4 months ago


Such an amazing sandwich! The meat to veggie ratio was perfect and the cheese was magnificent