Add Your Review

Thanks for visiting Gaetano's Sub Shop. We'd love to have your feedback!

Select a location

You are submitting your information to Gaetano's Sub Shop and Popmenu, which powers this site and is sponsoring this giveaway. Popmenu's and apply.

Our Latest Reviews

Crystal 11 months ago

Roast Beef and Pepper Jack

This tasted so good. I added mushrooms and bacon. Made it extra delicious.

Crystal 11 months ago

Italian

Absolutely amazing!!!

Cody 11 months ago

Turkey & Provolone

Best Turkey Sub in the state. Great Fries Great service

Adam 12 months ago

Hot Ham & Cheddar

Hot ham and cheese is my go-to at Gaetanos. I find better success placing custom orders in person than online though (like adding pickles to a sandwich).

Kasey 12 months ago

Italian

Kasey here! Embarking on this review is like trying to capture the essence of a sublime Italian sub that's been haunting my daydreams. Picture the finest capicola in the state, cozying up with hard salami, pepperoni, lettuce, tomato, provolone, impeccably cut white onions, mayo, and a dash of sub dressing -- all chilling on a cold sub. It's a masterpiece. Quick shoutout to Gaetano's "Inferno Sauce" -- a revelation for a saucy aficionado like me. Seriously, when you swing by for one of their sandwiches, don't sleep on asking for a side of this chipotle heaven. Your taste buds will thank you. Now, let's dive into the experience. Every time I waltz into this joint, it's like a warm welcome party. Multiple team members dish out the friendliness, making the whole experience of grabbing my food downright delightful. The owner is a local legend -- well-known, respected, and a massive supporter of other small businesses in the area. Meeting someone this awesome? Pure thrill. If you're into heavenly subs, killer sauces, and an all-around good vibe, this spot's your haven. Here's to mouthwatering bites and meeting the cool cats behind the counter! ??

Crystal 11 months ago

Turkey & Provolone

This is my personal favorite. It hits the spot.

Cody 11 months ago

Fries & Fry Sauce

crispy and delicious Fry sauce and inferno sauce is super good

Eriks 12 months ago

Italian

One of the best Italian subs in the city! Great value as well.

Mclovin 12 months ago

Philly

The Philly was great the best i have had in years!

Amanda about 1 year ago

Turkey & Provolone

This sub was huge and delicious! So much meat and maybe an entire avocado? It was well worth the money.